kickaha: (Default)
kickaha ([personal profile] kickaha) wrote2009-06-22 03:46 pm

Naming follies.

Gorilla Grodd. Who the heck calls themselves MySpecies MyName? I mean, a one-off hyper-intelligent member of said species maaaaaaaaybe, but Grodd comes from a whole race of intelligent gorillas. It'd be like running around in our society calling yourself Human Harold.

Yes, it's silly, but it just struck me as odd. (Yes, I know, I know... geeeeeeeeeeek...)

[identity profile] kickaha.livejournal.com 2009-06-22 08:19 pm (UTC)(link)
Oh I can understand other sentients using the species label first in many cases, what I find amusing is that he calls *himself* that.

I love the sheer inanity of this conversation. :D

[identity profile] badger.livejournal.com 2009-06-22 08:27 pm (UTC)(link)
(me, in Gorilla City, picking up the telephone)

*ring ring*

"GRUNT."

"(clears throat the way I have to before saying anything in German) Err, grunt. This is the Human Steve."

"What do you want, Silverface?"

[identity profile] kickaha.livejournal.com 2009-06-22 08:51 pm (UTC)(link)
If they ever had him throwing the definite article in there, it'd make more sense. "I am Human Steve" when in person and they can see you might be a bit of redundancy, no?

In retrospect, I think someone (Geoff Johns or Mark Waid, I can't recall who had control of the title at the time, I think Waid) noticed this in Flash - anytime the scene shifted to Gorilla City, or the humans were conversing with citizens of there, they just referred to him as "Grodd". Makes much more sense than a bunch of members of a species all prefacing their names with the bleedin' obvious. "Hi, I'm Human Steve." "Nice to meet you Human Steve, I'm Human Jason." "No kidding? On what side?"